How the three work
- An item holds one crafted mod. Spirit and Horror are both crafted, so having both needs Astrid's Creativity.
- The swap removes a random mod, possibly one you want. A Crystallisation omen can limit it to prefixes or to suffixes.
- The same currency can't be used again while its mod is on the item.
- Astrid's Creativity can't be taken out of its socket, but another rune can replace it. Socket it, add the second crafted mod, then put the Perfect Iron Rune in its place: you pay only for the rune.
What buyers pay for each suffix
We compared 554 listings of Sekhema Sandals with 35% Movement Speed, T1 increased and flat ES, quality 20, two Perfect Iron Runes and no corruption. The ES is counted without Horror's rune bonus, and each set is compared with three T1 resistances at the same ES:
Price against three T1 resistances at the same ES. H = Essence of Horror; “other” is any ordinary suffix: chaos resistance, rarity, an attribute.
Spirit keeps the price; Horror costs a quarter of it. Two resistances and Spirit sold about like three resistances, but that rests on 18 listings from 11 sellers. Horror sold no better than an ordinary third suffix, and every resistance you give up takes off another 10–15%.
Cost and profit, route by route
| Suffixes | Our cost | Sells for | Profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 × T1 resistance | 583 | 326 | loss |
| 2 × T1 resistance + Horror | 264 | 300 | +36 |
| 2 × T1 resistance + SpiritAs crafted, about 388 ES | 255 | 238 | −17 |
| 2 × T1 resistance + SpiritDivine Orbs to 406 ES | 269 | 351 | +82 |
| Spirit, Horror or both with Astrid's CreativityAny of: 3 × T1 resistance, 2 × T1 + Horror, 2 × T1 + Spirit, 1 × T1 + Horror + Spirit | — | — | ≈ Spirit |
| Horror, with T1 or T2 ES prefixes | 214 | 202 | ≈ −12 |
Divines per finished item, base included. Sells for: the cheapest quarter (25th percentile) of asks for boots with that suffix set and every resistance T1; for Spirit, adjusted to the boots' ES at 1.9% per point, because boots as crafted average 388 ES. Horror's ask barely follows ES (below), so it is taken as it is. A simulation of 500 crafts gave +81 for Spirit with Divine Orbs and +20 for Horror, lower than the solver's 36. With three resistances the solver doesn't start at all.
Spirit and Horror cost almost the same to make, 255 and 264. The difference is in what Divine Orbs do next. Spirit boots are paid by their ES: as crafted they sell for about 238, less than they cost, and rolled to 406 ES for about 351. On Horror boots there is nothing to roll for.
Letting the solver choose between finishes barely helps. Allowing every crafted finish through Astrid's Creativity added well under one divine to the Spirit route, and with rarity allowed as the third suffix the solver stopped on it once in 500 crafts.
Why Horror's ES doesn't sell
Horror boosts the runes, so with two Perfect Iron Runes the boots show about 40 more ES. That looks like a shortcut: the same shown ES with weaker prefixes and fewer Divine Orbs. Buyers don't pay for it.
At a shown ES of 400–419, boots with Horror and a T2 increased ES mod had a median ask of 210; boots without Horror and with T1, 333. Buyers look at the mods, not the total. The route that uses Horror to save on prefixes and Divine Orbs costs 214 and sells for about 202, the cheapest quarter of 12 such listings: it loses a little.
Use Horror as a suffix, not as ES. It still sells, at about the price of an ordinary third suffix, so a Horror finish makes money. Just don't count its extra ES in the price.
Astrid's Creativity: a rescue, not a route
With Astrid's Creativity a pair that lost a resistance can still finish as one resistance with Horror and Spirit. Without a Divine target only about 2% of finished boots ended that way, and the rescue added well under one divine per finished item.
The rescue finish sells for 162 against 324 for two resistances and Spirit. So it only pays when the alternative is starting over, and the more you invest in rolling ES, the less it is worth: with a Divine target of 400 ES or more, the solver used it in under 1% of attempts.
With Divine Orbs
Buyers paid about 1.9% more per point of ES. Rolling Divine Orbs until the total reaches 406–408 lifts the Spirit route from a loss of about 8 to about +82 per finished item. The Astrid route ends up exactly level with it, because at that ES it almost never rescues. Why 406 and how to roll for a total: Divining is solved. All routes against the market: Is crafting profitable?
The same routes on Sandsworn Sandals
Sandsworn Sandals roll the same mods with a 21–30 divine base instead of 70–80. Every route gets cheaper:
| Suffixes | Sekhema | Sandsworn |
|---|---|---|
| 3 × T1 resistance | 583 | 508 |
| 2 × T1 resistance + Spirit | 255 | 184 |
| With Astrid's Creativity | 181 | 131 |
Our cost per finished item, base included.
On Sandsworn the Astrid route turns into the Spirit route: 498 of 500 simulated crafts finished as two resistances and Spirit, because with a cheap base starting over is the better fix. Sandsworn tops out at 397 ES with quality 20.
Fine print
All measurements were taken on one date, 19 November 2026, in Forbidden Rites, with 75 divines as the price of a white Sekhema base and 25 for Sandsworn.
- Sale prices are the 25th percentile of asks for boots with the same suffix set and every resistance T1: quality 20, not corrupted, two sockets with two Perfect Iron Runes. Three quarters of comparable boots asked more; the median ask would add about 55 divines per item on the Spirit route. Asks are not sales.
- Price gaps between suffix sets come from a regression with ES and the month taken into account, errors grouped by seller. The Spirit cell is thin: 18 listings from 11 sellers in the regression, 15 from 9 with both resistances T1 in the price.
- Costs come from our craft solver with the option to start over on a new base.
+82
+36
+82