craftgaz
Runes of Aldur▾
  • Runes of Aldur✓
  • HC Runes of Aldur
  • Forbidden Rites Event
  • HC Forbidden Rites
  • Standard
  • Hardcore
helpPath of Exile 2 · patch 0.5+

Chaos Orb vs Exalted Orb vs Abyssal Bones: the cheapest way to start a rare craft

On Sekhema Sandals, Chaos Orbs land the first good mod for 1.78 divines when any of six target mods counts. A Preserved Rib looks cheaper for a narrow target, but a mod caught with a bone is worth nothing: the boots hold one desecrated mod, and the craft needs that slot at the end.

Chaos Orb1.78Chaos Orb
Preserved Rib2.46Preserved Rib + Abyssal Echoes
Exalted Orb7.04Exalted Orb
Divines per first target mod on Rare Sekhema Sandals, any of six mods counts. Icons: PoE2DB.

The question

The finished boots in this series have T1 increased ES, T1 flat ES and 35% Movement Speed as prefixes, and two T1 resistances plus a crafted Spirit suffix. You start from a Rare pair with one mod you don't want, the usual state after a miss. What is the cheapest way to get the first mod you keep?

We count six mods as a hit: T1 increased ES, T1 flat ES, 35% Movement Speed, and T1 fire, cold or lightning resistance. Each has the same chance to roll, 0.91% per Chaos Orb.

Every method, priced

Divines per first target modAverage divines to land one of six target mods: Chaos Orb 1.78, Preserved Rib with Omen of Abyssal Echoes 2.46, Greater Orb of Augmentation on a Magic item 3.80, Preserved Rib 4.00, Greater Exalted Orb with Annulment 4.29, Exalted Orb 7.04.02468Chaos1.78Rib + Echoes2.46Greater Aug3.80Rib4.00Exalt + Annul4.29Exalted7.04

Average divines to land one of the six mods. Blue: the same boots as a Magic item.

MethodHit chanceDivines per hit
Chaos Orb5.48%1.78
Preserved Rib + Omen of Abyssal EchoesA bone-caught mod is worth nothing here, see below19.12%2.46
Greater Orb of Augmentation Magic10.16%3.80
Preserved Rib10.07%4.00
Perfect Orb of Augmentation Magic16.46%4.22
Greater Exalted Orb10.16%4.29
Exalted Orb5.48%7.04
Orb of Augmentation Magic5.48%7.05
Ancient Rib + Omen of Abyssal Echoes38.58%16.97
Perfect Exalted Orb16.46%21.67
Ancient Rib21.63%29.95

Hit chance per try. Every route except Chaos first removes the unwanted mod with an Orb of Annulment, and removes each miss the same way.

A Chaos Orb costs about 0.10 divines and swaps the unwanted mod for a new one, so a miss leaves the boots ready for the next try. Every other try costs an orb plus an Orb of Annulment, 0.39, to clear the miss. The Exalted Orb itself costs almost nothing, so a try is about 0.39 divines, four times a Chaos Orb, for the same 5.48% chance; the Greater Exalted Orb hits more often, because it skips low tiers, but still costs 4.29 per hit.

Count any of the six T1 mods as a hit

The more mods count as a hit, the cheaper the first one. Every tier rolls equally often, so T1 is one roll in six to eight even within the right family: any tier of these six families would land every 2–3 Chaos Orbs, the T1 versions only once in 18. Narrow targets make bones look good, but what a first mod saves later is small:

A hit isChaos,
div
Bone,
div
Saved,
div
Any of the six T1 mods5.48% per Chaos Orb1.7818 orbs2.461.80
A T1 resistance2.74% per Chaos Orb3.5636 orbs2.972.88
Any T1 prefixincreased ES, flat ES, 35% MS; 2.74% per Chaos Orb3.5636 orbs1.460.72
T1 increased ES only0.91% per Chaos Orb10.67110 orbs3.981.24

Chaos: how many Chaos Orbs a hit takes on average (5.48% is about 1 in 18), and what they cost in divines at about 0.10 divines per orb. Bone: the same cost in divines with the best bone, a Preserved Rib with Omen of Abyssal Echoes, plus an Orb of Annulment for each miss. Saved: how much less the rest of the craft costs, on average, once a Chaos Orb lands that mod.

Only “any of the six” pays for itself: about 18 Chaos Orbs, worth 1.78 divines, to roll it, and 1.80 divines saved later. Chasing increased ES alone takes about 110 Chaos Orbs, worth 10.67 divines, to save 1.24. The bone column looks cheap, but a bone-caught mod saves nothing at all.

Why a bone is the wrong start

An item holds one desecrated mod (only an Omen of Putrefaction gives more). This craft spends its bone at the very end: in 100 simulated crafts every finished pair had exactly one desecrated mod, most often flat ES (37), Movement Speed (32) or increased ES (21), and the bones cost about 27 divines per finished item.

A first mod caught with a Preserved Rib takes that slot. To use the last bone you have to remove it again, so the boots are no better than with a junk mod:

193.10craft left with a bone-caught T1 resistance
193.10craft left with a junk mod

Save the bone for the last mod. At the end it aims at a slot you can't fill cheaply any other way. At the start it buys a mod the Chaos Orb gets you for 1.78.

How bones and their omens work: desecration in PoE2.

Which first mod to keep

Keep any of the six. The rest of the craft is still to pay with any of them, so the choice moves the total by a few divines out of about 268:

First mod on the bootsCraft leftSaved
T1 resistance190.222.88
T1 increased ES191.861.24
35% Movement Speed192.520.58
T1 flat ES192.770.33
Junk mod, or any mod caught with a bone193.10—

Expected divines still to spend on a Rare pair with only that mod, the base already paid for.

A T1 resistance is worth the most for the same reason it is the best mod to fracture: two resistances have to come out of a big suffix pool with nothing to steer them. The prefixes can be finished with aimed tools later, so having one early saves less.

The two tools agree. Chaos Orbs cost 1.78 for a hit, and a hit leaves 191.30 on average; together that is 193.08, against the solver's 193.10 for the junk-mod boots. Chaos Orbs until any of the six lands is the solver's own plan from here.

Why not keep the boots Magic

A Magic item has no Chaos Orb. Each try is an Orb of Annulment to clear the item and an Orb of Augmentation to add a mod. The Greater Orb of Augmentation does that for 3.80 per hit, a little cheaper than the Greater Exalted Orb on a Rare, but still twice the Chaos Orb. The plain Orb of Augmentation costs the same as the Exalted Orb, 7.05.

Fine print

All measurements were taken on one date, 19 November 2026, in Forbidden Rites, with 75 divines as the price of a white base.

  • Every number is for Sekhema Sandals, item level 82. Sandsworn Sandals have the same mod pool, so the first mod costs the same there.
  • Hit costs come from Constructor's roll first mod; craft left comes from our craft solver for boots with two Perfect Iron Runes, quality 20 and Divine Orbs until total ES reaches 406 (why 406).
  • Bones are modeled with the reveal screen measured on rings (how it works); boots weren't measured.